WhodunlieCase file No. 004Today's case
The Switched Labels
Valdelena winery, the check before dispatch. Two thousand eight hundred bottles came off the bottling line wearing reserva labels. The laboratory has analysed six at random: four of them hold the young wine from tank eight, which costs a fifth as much. The label run adds up, the line record adds up, and the lorry leaves at seven in the morning.
Exactly 2 of the 7 are lying
A liar lies about everything they say.
Hard evidenceAlways true. They are your anchors.
1The log for the bottling line records exactly one person during the incident.
2The log for the office records exactly one person during the incident.
Plan and suspectsPlace the suspects where they were during the incident. Each room’s eye shows what can be seen from it.
Tap a token to select it, then tap a room on the plan. Tap a placed token to send it back.
♀Araminta
Owner of the estate
I never left the press house. What Odelia is telling you is the truth. We were 2 in my room, not one more.
♂Osmund
Press house foreman
I never left the shop. There was nobody there but me. What Cyprian is telling you is the truth.
♀Odelia
The owner's niece
The office is where I was. In the bottling line, which I could see from my spot, there was one person.
♂Bastian
Grower of the high plot
I never left the laboratory. With me was Hermione.
♂Anastasius
Cellar foreman
I was hanging around the laboratory. 2 of us were in there. Araminta is not lying.
♂Cyprian
Cooper
The press house is where I was. What Araminta is telling you is the truth.
♀Hermione
Official taster
I was over in the press house. I was with Cyprian. Odelia was in the shop.
1· · ·
2· · ·
3· · ·
4· · ·
5· · ·
6· · ·
7· · ·
8· · ·
9· · ·
10· · ·
Place all 7 on the plan